
Who Pays for the Bull Market
It has been nearly six years since "The Clear Long Bull from the West". After two cycles, crypto has finally fulfilled most of the "wish lists" from the past decade. The things described in that article are happening rapidly: various allocation institutions are deploying into Bitcoin, products linking to TradFi are fully integrated, Circle is going public with a high profile, and the U.S. President has publicly endorsed and even launched his own meme coin. By the old script, this should be the standard opening of a "high-beta bull market." But what we have seen after this cycle is a collapse in volatility, market catalysts being front-run, and an industry that should have been full of "surprises" is no longer exciting as assets become fully financialized and mainstreamed.
Across asset classes, even against a backdrop of policy friendliness and institutional dividend releases, BTC significantly underperformed gold, U.S. stocks, Hong Kong stocks, A-shares, and other major TradFi assets in 2025. It is one of the few assets that failed to follow global risk assets to new highs.

Starting in early 2024, I posted multiple times on my English Twitter account @DoveyWan from different perspectives deconstructing the structural changes in the liquidity supply chain caused by asset mainstreaming. Let me pick a few representative points:
When the participant structure and liquidity supply chain of Crypto have already undergone substantial changes: Who is buying? Who is selling? And who is quietly leaving?
The Great Divergence Between Offshore and Onshore Capital
To understand the capital structure of this cycle, we first need to deconstruct BTC's three key highs in this cycle:
Phase A (Nov 2024 – Jan 2025): Trump's election and improved regulatory expectations triggered FOMO across the entire onshore + offshore market, with BTC breaking $100,000 for the first time.
Phase B (Apr 2025 – mid-Aug 2025): After a deleveraging correction, BTC surged again, breaking $120,000 for the first time.
Phase C (early Oct 2025): BTC recorded its local ATH for this cycle, followed shortly by the 10·10 flash crash, entering an adjustment period.
From the combination of spot and derivatives, the three phases share several common characteristics:
Spot: Onshore is the main buyer, Offshore tends to reduce positions at highs. Coinbase Premium maintained a positive premium during all three topping phases (A/B/C), indicating that buying pressure at highs mainly came from onshore spot funds represented by Coinbase.

Coinbase BTC Balance continued to decline during the cycle, reducing sellable筹码 on the CEX side. In contrast, Binance Balance rose significantly with price rebounds in phases B and C, corresponding to increased potential selling pressure from offshore spot.

Offshore OI denominated in BTC (using Binance BTC OI as an example) continued to rise in phases B and C, with leverage increasing. Even after the 10·10 deleveraging caused a short-term drop, it quickly recovered to high levels and even hit new highs. In contrast, onshore futures OI represented by CME has been declining since early 2025 and did not recover simultaneously when prices hit new highs.
At the same time, BTC volatility diverged from price. Especially when BTC first broke $120,000 in August 2025, Deribit DVOL was at a cyclical low, and implied volatility did not give a premium to the new high, indicating that the options market was cautious in pricing trend continuation.


Spot is a portfolio rebalancing behavior for major asset classes. The divergence in behavior between the two sides reflects a disagreement on long-term confidence in the asset. The players on CME and in options are the smart money most sensitive to the smell of blood, with extremely keen instincts. The difference in trading setup and timing control between the two sides is clear.
"Institutions" with Deep Pockets but Little Smarts?
At the beginning of 2025, two key policies laid the foundation for the structural entry of onshore buying:
These two changes provided the accounting and compliance prerequisites for subsequent DAT, corporate treasuries, and some institutional fund allocations. So we also started receiving a large number of financing pitches from new DAT players entering the market in Q1 2025. The core capability of a DAT founding team is just one thing: fundraising ability. So-called institutions are not smarter than retail investors; they just have lower capital costs and more financial tools for continuous fundraising.
According to Glassnode statistics, the amount of BTC held by DAT companies rose from approximately 197,000 BTC in early 2023 to about 1.08 million BTC by the end of 2025, a net increase of about 890,000 BTC in two years. DAT has become one of the most important structural buyers in this cycle. The operating logic of DAT can be summarized as NAV premium arbitrage:
Taking MSTR as an example, its large-scale position increases and largest convertible bond issuances in 2024–2025 were highly concentrated in periods when BTC was strongly rising, approaching or hitting new all-time highs:
Therefore, for DAT, adding positions at highs is not chasing the trend but an inevitable result of maintaining the stock price premium and balance sheet structure.
Another frequently misunderstood aspect is ETF flow. The investor structure of ETFs has the following characteristics:
Slightly breaking down the ETF fund structure reveals that institutions are not the majority. These institutions are not using their own balance sheet money; asset management and hedge funds are certainly not "diamond hands" in the traditional sense.

As for other types of institutions, they are not smarter than retail investors either. Institutions have only two business models: charging management fees and charging carry. Our industry's top-tier VC from the 2016 vintage, a top-tier Crypto VC, has a DPI of only 2.4x (meaning $100 invested in 2014 yielded $240 in 2024). This significantly underperforms Bitcoin's growth over the past 10 years. The advantage of retail investors is always to go with the flow, to be able to turn around quickly after understanding changes in market structure, without being path-dependent. Most institutional investors die from path dependency and degradation of self-iteration ability; most exchanges die from misappropriation of user assets and security vulnerabilities.
The Absent Retail Investor
Looking at the site traffic of several top CEXs like Binance and Coinbase, overall visits have been declining since the peak of the 2021 bull market, and did not recover significantly even when BTC hit new highs. This is in stark contrast to the booming traffic of Robinhood next door. For more, you can read our article from last year "Where are the marginal buyers"

Binance Traffic

Coinbase traffic
The "wealth effect" in 2025 was more concentrated outside of crypto. S&P 500 (+18%), Nasdaq (+22%), Nikkei (+27%), Hang Seng (+30%), KOSPI (+75%), and even A-shares rose nearly 20%, not to mention Gold (+70%) and Silver (+144%). Furthermore, Crypto faced a 'kill' in this cycle: AI stocks provided a stronger wealth effect narrative, while 0DTE (Zero-Day Options) in U.S. stocks offered an even more casino-like experience than perps, and new retail investors were flocking to Polymarket and Kalshi to gamble on various macro and political events.
In addition, even South Korean retail investors, known for high-frequency speculation, have retreated from Upbit in this round and turned to all-in on KOSPI and US stocks. In 2025, Upbit's average daily trading volume fell ~80% compared to the same period in 2024, while over the same period, the KOSPI index rose over 70%–75% for the full year. South Korean retail investors' net purchases of US stocks reached a record $31 billion
Emerging Sellers
At a time when BTC and US tech stocks are increasingly moving in sync, a clear divergence emerged in August 2025: after following ARKK and NVDA to an August peak, BTC fell behind and experienced the 1011 crash, from which it has not yet recovered. Coincidentally, at the end of July 2025, Galaxy disclosed in its earnings report and press release that it had completed the phased sale of over 80,000 BTC on behalf of an early BTC holder within 7–9 days. These signs indicate that Crypto native capital is undergoing massive handovers with institutions.

As BTC wrapper products (such as IBIT, etc.) mature, the完善的金融设施为BTC OG巨鲸提供了流动退出的最佳渠道。OG 的行为从“在交易所直接按市价卖出”,升级为利用BTC结构化产品退出或者进行资产轮动,进入更为广阔的Tradfi资产世界。Galaxy and the biggest business growth in 2025 came from helping BTC whales rotate their BTC into iBit. iBit's collateral mobility is far superior to native BTC, and it is safe and easy to custody. As assets go mainstream, the high capital efficiency of paper Bitcoin far exceeds that of real Bitcoin, which is the inevitable path for other precious metals to become financialized.
Miners: From "Paying Electricity Bills" to "Raising CAPEX for AI"
From around the 2024 halving to the end of 2025, it has been the most sustained and largest downward cycle in miner reserves since 2021: as of the end of 2025, miner reserves stood at approximately 1.806 million BTC, with the hash rate falling about 15% year-over-year, indicating industry consolidation and structural transformation.
More importantly, the motivation for miners to sell coins in this round has gone beyond the traditional "covering electricity costs":
Financialized Paper Bitcoin
Bitcoin and the crypto digital assets it represents are undergoing a slow migration from the inside out, shifting from value-discovery active trading dominated by crypto native capital to passive allocation and balance sheet management represented by ETFs, DATs, sovereign and long-term capital, and the positions managed are often financialized paper Bitcoin. The underlying asset Bitcoin is gradually becoming a risk asset component stuffed into various portfolios and bought according to weight. Bitcoin's mainstreaming process is complete, but it brings with it a cycle of leverage and systemic fragility similar to traditional finance.
Where to Go
Under the new liquidity structure, the traditional narrative of "halving every four years equals one full cycle" is no longer sufficient to explain BTC's price behavior. The dominant variables in the coming years will come more from two axes:
In these four quadrants:

In 2026, we will gradually move from the right quadrants to the left quadrants, getting closer to the "Loose + Discount" or "Slightly Loose + Discount" boxes in our framework. At the same time, 2026 will also see several key institutional and market variables:
Is price important? Of course. Having crossed the $100,000 mark, Bitcoin has used its price to make this young asset, only 17 years old, a strategic reserve at the national level. Beyond price, the next journey for crypto assets remains long. As I wrote in 2018 when founding Primitive, in "Hello, Primitive Ventures":
"In our exploration of the crypto industry over the past few years, we have seen the power of distributed consensus reached among individuals, and the characteristic that information will 'continuously dissipate,' giving crypto assets strong vitality. It is precisely the most fundamental desire of individuals for freedom and equality, and for the certainty of assets and data, that allows us to see the possibility that 'entropy always increases, crypto lives forever.'"
When capital markets and cultural trends intertwine, they can unleash economic and production relations reforms more powerful than the cultural trends themselves. The populist finance represented by crypto is the most typical product of the intertwining of "capital markets + cultural trends."
If in the coming years, we can see the crypto rail, as the only supranational and globalized liquidity infrastructure, generate a large number of applications with沉淀 cash flows, users, and balance sheets, allowing some of the fruits of ETF/DAT victories to flow back on-chain, transforming passive allocation into active usage, then everything we say today will not be the end of a cycle, but rather the starting point of the next truly adoption phase. From Code is the law, to Code is eating the bank. We have already walked through the most difficult 15 years.
The beginning of a revolution means the decay of the beliefs of the old era. The worship of Rome made the Roman civilization's dominance of the world a "self-fulfilling prophecy." The birth process of the new god may be random, but the twilight of the old god is already predetermined.
P.S.: This article is an in-depth review of the article "A Clear Long Bull from the West" written six years ago. Thank you to those who have been with us since 2017, or even earlier. We have witnessed Bitcoin move from narrative to sovereignty, from the fringe to the mainstream, and we have also experienced together those beliefs that only those who were there can understand.
Also, thanks to the team colleagues at Primitive Ventures. This article was jointly completed by me and our taciturn but hardcore researcher Ada @adaYen72